Re: rsync README and <http://rsync.samba.org/rsync/nt.html>

[David Starks-Browning <starksb at ebi dot ac dot uk>]

On Wednesday 14 Nov 01, Lapo Luchini writes:
> > Could you create a setup.hint file with this information in it?  If you
> > look at the current setup.ini, you'll see the short description for rsync.
> > If you could just create a setup.ini with an updated 'requires' line
> > then I'll install it.  It should probably look something like:
> >
> > requires cygrunsrv bash zlib
> >
> > (I don't know what it actually requires but hopefully you get the idea)
> 
> -cygrunsrv is required only to use it as a rsync:// server (in --daemon mode)
> -zlib is not used (rsync currently uses a modified version that's in its
> source)
> -ssh is required for acces via ssh, of course.. but not for rsync:// servers
> -bash is only required for commodity, but of course works perfectly in CMD.EXE
> if path is correct
> 
> Uhm... it seems that actually it requires... nothing.
> I have still to put up a "clean system" with only the rsync package installed
> though (and the obvious cygwin package, but I bet that one needs not to be
> specified in "requires"... it's required by every package...) but "Dependency
> Walker" shows only cygwin1, kernel32 and ntdll; as does KillProcess tool to
> see which DLL are used "in memory"..

Lapo,

I don't think you need to build a "clean system" to verify this.
That's a rather onerous task.

People should be smart enough to know that if they want to use
rsync+ssh then they also have to get ssh.  It shouldn't be your
problem (or rather, setup's) to *suggest* what other things might be
useful.

However, you *should* document the cygrunsrv & ssh requirements in the
/usr/docs/Cygwin/rsync-<ver>.README file.

That's my opinion, anyway.

Regards,
David