This is the mail archive of the
ecos-discuss@sources.redhat.com
mailing list for the eCos project.
Re: Red Hat backs away from eCos?
- From: Kjell Svensson <kjell at techtribe dot se>
- To: ecos-discuss at sources dot redhat dot com
- Date: Thu, 20 Jun 2002 09:35:32 +0200
- Subject: Re: [ECOS] Red Hat backs away from eCos?
- References: <F148C3hSsxLtBH49KOl00002201@hotmail.com>
Hi,
Bruce Smith wrote:
Michael Kelly wrote:
HI,
For what it's worth, I say good riddance. Red Hat never knew what
to do with eCOs or even GNU for that matter. Now that the eCos
source is GPL'ed (with appropriate modifiers for embedded use), I
believe it will take off. I intend to show my support by working with
some of the developers to create board/eCos bundles for development
use. I encourage all of the board vendors out there to do the same.
I agree. And by developers I assume you mean those laid off? I still
see activity from familiar names though no longer with Red Hat email
addresses :-) Who will maintain eCOs if Red Hat are not?
I have also with satisfaction noted that some people from the former
Cygus/RedHat/eCos developer team is still talking to the list. I surely
hope most of these developers will be able to keep on working with
open-source eCos.
And as for end users, support eCos by working with the developers
and funding the projects. Maybe now they can take on reasonable
size jobs since they do not have to meet the inflated levels of revenue
Red Hat expected of each customer.
There were rumours of an eCOs startup. Does anyone know what happened to
that? Did their VC fall through, or are they still looking for VC?
I'm myself not sure whether VC-financing is the right thing for embedded
open-source projects - I have seen more than one well-working company
(maybe Cygnus is a good example?) that has lost much of its business
potential when VC:s have come in trying to boost revenues to unhealty
levels. And it usually don't seem to be any better if such a company
eventually goes off for an IPO...
"Jim" (jyl087@netscape.net) suggested that chip manufacturers should
form a coalition group sponsoring further eCos development. While I
believe this is a beautiful idea, my experience with silicon
manufacturers unfortunately makes me pessimistic to whether this would
be realistic.
Instead, I'd suggest that we who are today part of the eCos user
community join together, founding and sponsoring an eCos startup company
who could safely bring a truly open-source eCos further!
If we move on fast, hopefully we could maybe even attract some of the
original eCos developers to this eCos startup before they will have to
switch over to other businesses
While I doubt such a company would be able to produce revenue levels
interesting enough to a VC, I'm positive that it could safely provide a
sound financial ground for a smaller number of developers continuing the
eCos development in a truly open-source spirit. And with the help from
contributions from a more dedicated "sponsorship community", I believe
the speed of furter eCos development could even be improved.
I suggest anyone interested in helping sponsoring an eCos startup
(indications from users about being willing to buy servicess from such a
startup would probably be the most valuabe item!) tell this to this
list, so that we can see it this could be a possible route to take.
Anyway, I think an eCos free from Red Hat is good for the embedded
world and I do not believe it will die off.
I agree. Red Hat were becoming the Microsoft of the Open Source world so
this can only be a good thing.
regards
bruce
_________________________________________________________________
Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com/intl.asp.
Cheers, /Kjell
--
Kjell Svensson Embedded Technology Manager
Techtribe Solutions AB Tel: +46 (0)31 706 06 00
Flöjelbergsgatan 12 GSM: +46 (0)70 270 76 66
SE-431 37 MÖLNDAL Mail: kjell@techtribe.se
Sweden
--
Before posting, please read the FAQ: http://sources.redhat.com/fom/ecos
and search the list archive: http://sources.redhat.com/ml/ecos-discuss