This is the mail archive of the
mailing list for the Cygwin project.
Re: [FAQ?] Re: [Mingw-users] Cygwin Full download in one big archive?
Robert Collins wrote:
Errmm...I musta missed something. I wasn't suggesting you do any such
I'm not about to actively maintain two forms of setup that are so
different. And until someone offers to do that, I think it is a
reasonable assumption to make that the install form you start with you
Right, it wasn't germane to the "how the heck can I **download**
everything" problem. Setup, as we all know, is NOT a generic mirroring
Also, I supported having a 'install-in-one-hit-everything' in setup
earlier in my email, where you did not quote.
Sortof. I assumed <i>a priori</i> that a 557MB tarball is a bad idea.
It was discussed in one of the two messages I posted a link to. IIRC
this whole thread started because somebody wanted to download the whole
cygwin schlmeil in order to *inspect* the binaries or sources; not to
install it. And he didn't relish an afternoon's worth of point-n-click.
Now, for grabbing everything at once, there are many ways:
wget ~= setup ~= winwget ~= ftp mget ~= tool foo
and they are *all* orthogonal to the monolithic download discussion.
I thought "installation" wasn't the issue ANYWAY. It was just
*downloading*. It's a given that we are NOT going to make 600MB
tarballs, or daily-updated .iso's. So, how to solve the original
poster's problem (and address the somewhat squirrelly issue of modem users)?
I'm trying to highlight the weakness's with a monolithic download, not
the pros and cons of a full-install strategy.
I suggested using a a reasonable fascimile of a mirroring tool (e.g.
wget, plus a GUI for the cmdline-challenged) to handle the *download*.
I didn't say (because I thought it was obvious) that IF one wanted to
actually install cygwin -- which was NOT the case for the original
poster who started this thread, I think -- you'd use setup.exe and point
it at the nice local collection of files wget downloaded for you. And
then for updates, you'd point setup.exe back to the normal mirrors.
I was not, in any way, suggesting that setup learn how to parse a cygwin
"installation" created by some moron unzipping a bunch of tarballs by
hand. No way. Never.
Unsubscribe info: http://cygwin.com/ml/#unsubscribe-simple
Bug reporting: http://cygwin.com/bugs.html